https://buymeacoffee.com/sweetandcondensed
It’s 2026, and we are starting the year off with the guys back all together! (We missed you on the pod, though, Kelly).
After a year-long hiatus, New Mexico Drew has finally returned to the Sweet and Condensed microphone. Naturally, we had to welcome him back with a movie that is equal parts stressful, hilarious, and bizarre: Josh Safdie’s Marty Supreme.
In this episode, we break down why this film about professional ping pong feels more like a heist movie. We discuss the incredible supporting cast—including a non-actor found ranting after a Knicks game and Shark Tank’s Kevin O’Leary —and debate whether the “Uncut Gems” anxiety is actually charming this time around.
Highlights include:
The Comeback: Drew explains where he’s been (sort of) and why we’re all on a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP).
The Music: Why 1980s synth perfectly fits 1950s New York.
The Verdict: Is this Timothée Chalamet’s best performance? And is the movie a top 5 contender for the year?
Marty Supreme: Spoilers #67
🎧 Listen to this episode on Apple Podcasts or Spotify
🎥 Watch this episode on YouTube
New Mexico Drew returns from the wilderness (and a year-long hiatus) to join Josh and Eric for a chaotic deep dive into Josh Safdie’s Marty Supreme.
The boys are breaking down the electric world of professional ping pong, the unique 1950s-meets-1980s aesthetic, and why Timothée Chalamet might just be playing himself.
They discuss the standout supporting cast—from Kevin O’Leary (yes, Mr. Wonderful) to Tyler, the Creator—and debate whether the film lands in their top movies of the year. Spoilers ahead!
Timestamps
00:00 – Intro: The return of New Mexico Drew, PIPs, and safely ignoring the editors.
03:40 – First reactions: Heavy-handed themes, rampant comedy, and “Uncut Gems” energy.
05:30 – Letterboxd check: Plot summary and the stacked cast list.
08:00 – Safdie Vibes: Comparisons to Uncut Gems and Good Time.
10:20 – Textures: How it compares to Benny Safdie’s The Smashing Machine.
13:00 – Character Study: Why we root for Marty despite the toxicity.
16:00 – Standout Performances: Luke Manley’s acting debut, Kevin O’Leary’s “Mr. Wonderful” persona, and Tyler, the Creator.
21:30 – The “Rocky” Tropes: 1980s Cold War energy in a 1950s setting.
26:00 – Memorable Scenes: The bathtub incident and the white-shirt finale.
28:10 – The Needle Drops: Using modern synth to score a period piece.
31:10 – That visual metaphor: Sperm, eggs, and ping pong balls.
33:30 – Final Ratings: Is it a Top 5 movie?
Movies Mentioned
Subscribe to Sweet & Condensed! A weekly newsletter that lets you know at a glance if the latest box office releases are worth your time and money and what to expect if you decide to go.
Why you'll love it - Think all the movie love and fun, none of the snobbery. We're doing this because we love people, movies, and the magic that lives where they meet.
Support us on Patreon!
https://www.patreon.com/SweetAndCondensed
Connect with us!
YouTube:
@SweetAndCondensed
Instagram:
@_SweetAndCondensed_
Twitter:
@justjoshperez
@EricHarrison
@NewMexicoDrew
Letterboxd:
@NewMexicoDrew
@ericharrison
@JustJoshPerez
@kellyharrison
The Sweet and Condensed podcast is a Three Milks Media production.